📅 October 2026
🌎 International Trade and Trade Defense
📚 Technical reference article
Is selling below cost dumping?
In a meeting with the board of directors of an exporting company, the question is usually phrased like this: «They accuse us of dumping, but we don't sell below cost. How can that be?»
The answer is unsettling because it dismantles the most widespread idea on the subject. Dumping, in a legal sense, It's not about selling below cost, It's not about selling cheaper than the competition, nor about offering the lowest price on the market. It's something more precise and, at the same time, easier to configure than many companies assume: to export a product at a price lower than its normal value.
This technical difference is what determines whether a company faces an antidumping duty of 0% or 80%. Here we explain what dumping is according to the World Trade Organization (WTO), how the margin is calculated, and why the same case can yield different results in Washington, Brussels, or Buenos Aires.
Key concept: Dumping is a comparison between two prices for the same product from the same exporter: the price charged when exporting and the price considered «normal» in the country of origin. It is not a comparison with the price of competitors in the importing country.
The legal definition: Article VI of the GATT and Article 2 of the Antidumping Agreement
The definition has two sources that should be read together. Article VI of the GATT 1994 It describes dumping as the introduction of products from one country into the market of another at a price lower than their normal value, and declares it condemnable only when it causes or threatens to cause material damage to a domestic industry, or materially delays its establishment.
He Agreement on the Implementation of Article VI of the GATT 1994 (the WTO Antidumping Agreement) operationalizes that idea in its Article 2.1A product is considered dumped when its export price is lower than the comparable price, in the ordinary course of trade, of a like product intended for consumption in the exporting country. The full texts can be found in our section Multilateral Resources.
Three practical consequences:
- Dumping alone does not warrant a measure. The importing country's authority must also prove damage (Article 3) and a causal relationship between the two.
- Dumping is not illegal. Selling cheaply abroad is a legitimate business decision. The system neither prohibits nor penalizes it: it allows the importing country to neutralize its harmful effect through an additional customs duty. We elaborate on this point in What is the WTO and why does antidumping law exist?
- The conduct is the exporter's, but the tax is paid by the importer. The importing country has no jurisdiction over the foreign company; therefore, the remedy falls on the import itself. For the importer, dumping by its supplier is a personal risk.
The two terms of the equation: export price and normal value
The export price
It is the most accessible term: the selling price for export to the investigating country, normally at FOB level, taken from customs statistics and, if the case is open, from the exporter's invoices.
The problem arises when that price is unreliable. Article 2.3 The Agreement contemplates two scenarios: that there is no export price or that it is unreliable due to a association or compensatory arrangement between exporter and importer. In that case, the authority can reconstruct it from the price at which the product is first resold to a independent buyer, discounting backwards the costs and the reasonable profit margin from resale.
Here's a trap we frequently see in multinational groups. The transfer price that the company defends before the tax authorities—documented, even validated by a transfer pricing study— does not obligate the antidumping authority. If the importing subsidiary resells at a loss or with an abnormally low margin, the authority will reconstruct an export price lower than the invoiced price, and the dumping margin will increase. In the United States, this is known as constructed export price (CEP) and is one of the most common sources of high margins.
Attention: In a related group, the profitability of the importing subsidiary in the destination country is, in fact, part of the dumping calculation. A market penetration strategy financed by the subsidiary can be interpreted as dumping even if the parent company invoices «at market price.».
The normal value
It is the most disputed term, because the information that best supports it is in the hands of the exporter. The Agreement establishes a hierarchy:
- Price in the domestic market of the exporting country, in the course of normal business operations. This is the general rule.
- Appropriate export price to a third country, provided it is representative.
- Reconstructed value: cost of production in the country of origin plus a reasonable amount for administrative, sales and general expenses, and for profit (Article 2.2).
The first alternative is only abandoned when domestic sales do not allow for an adequate comparison: because they do not exist, because their volume is low —note 2 of the Agreement normally considers a domestic volume equal to or greater than 5% of the sales exported to the investigating country to be sufficient— or because of a special market situation.
Furthermore, the Article 2.2.1 It allows for the exclusion from the calculation of internal sales made below cost when they occur over a prolonged period, in substantial quantities, and at prices that do not allow for the recovery of costs within a reasonable time. Note 5 establishes the practical benchmark: substantial quantities are defined as those where the weighted average price is below the weighted average cost, or where sales below cost represent at least 20% of the volume considered.
Consequence: The cheapest domestic sales are the first that the authority will try to eliminate., And its exclusion raises the normal value. Article 2.2.1.1 obliges the authority to use the exporter's accounting records, provided they follow the generally accepted accounting principles of their country and reasonably reflect the product's costs. Disorganized cost accounting is not an administrative problem: it's a higher dumping margin.
The case of non-market economies
When domestic prices are fixed or heavily distorted by the state, Note 15 of Article VI of the GATT allows for deviations from these fixed prices and the use of prices or costs from a third country. In the case of China, which joined in 2001, Section 15 of its Accession Protocol allowed Members to use alternative methodologies for 15 years, with one provision expiring on December 11, 2016.
USA It keeps China on its list of non-market economies and calculates normal value using factors of production valued in a substitute country. European Union It eliminated the list in 2017 and replaced it with the concept of «significant distortions» (Article 2, paragraph 6 bis, of Regulation (EU) 2016/1036), which allows the normal value to be constructed using undistorted international prices and costs. In both cases, the normal value is not calculated using the exporter's own costs.
How to calculate the dumping margin, step by step
Once both terms are constructed, the margin is expressed as the difference between normal value and export price, in relation to a denominator:
Dumping margin = (Normal value − Export price) ÷ Export price
Before applying the formula, the Article 2.4 requires a fair comparisonBoth prices must be converted to the same commercial level—normally ex-works—and refer to sales from dates as close together as possible. Any differences that are shown to affect comparability (sales conditions, taxation, quantities, physical characteristics, among others) are adjusted. Currency conversions are made at the exchange rate on the date of sale (Article 2.4.1).
An example with numbers
Let's assume an industrial valve manufacturer who, after adjustments, sells in its domestic market to USD 1,200 per unit at the ex-factory level. Exports the same valve to USD 980 FOB; discounting an inland freight of USD 30 to the port, the ex-factory export price is USD 950.
- Absolute difference: 1,200 − 950 = USD 250 per unit.
- Margin on the export price: 250 ÷ 950 = 26,3 %.
However, the percentage depends on the denominator used by each jurisdiction. European Commission This represents the margin on the CIF price at the Union border, excluding unpaid duties. If we add USD 60 for international freight and insurance to USD 980 FOB, the CIF price is USD 1,040, and the same absolute dumping is expressed as 250 ÷ 1,040 = 24,0 %. Same dumping, two percentages: never compare margins from different jurisdictions without verifying their basis.
The three comparison methods and why they change the result
He Article 2.4.2 It provides three methods:
- Weighted average vs. weighted averageThe usual method. An average normal value is compared with an average export price of all comparable transactions.
- Transaction by transaction: useful when the operations are few and heterogeneous, as in capital goods.
- Weighted average versus individual transactions: exceptional. It only applies if the authority identifies a significantly different export pricing pattern depending on buyers, regions, or periods (the so-called targeted dumping) and explains why the other two methods do not allow it to be captured.
Let's see why choice matters. With a normal value of 100, an exporter makes three sales in the investigated period:
| Sale | Amount | Export price | Difference with VN (100) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 500 | 110 | -10 |
| B | 300 | 104 | -4 |
| C | 200 | 85 | +15 |
The weighted average export price is 103.2. Compared to a normal value of 100, the result is negative (−3.1%): there is no dumping. But if the authority only adds up the positive differences and zeroes out the negative ones, the total dumping is 15 × 200 = 3,000 on an exported value of 103,200: a margin of 2.9%, enough to exceed the threshold de minimis and enable a measure.
That practice is the zeroing (reduction to zero). The Appellate Body declared it incompatible with the Agreement in comparisons between averages (USA – Softwood V, DS264), in periodic reviews and in transaction-by-transaction comparisons (US – Zero emissions (EC), DS294; US – Reduction to zero (Japan), DS322) and, later, also within the average versus transactions method (USA – Washing Machines, DS464). The United States withdrew from the zeroing in comparisons between averages, but the Department of Commerce (DOC) maintains an analysis of «differential prices» which, when activated, can reintroduce similar effects.
The thresholds that close a case
He Article 5.8 requires the investigation to be terminated immediately when the dumping margin is de minimis —lower than 2 % of the export price—or when a country's import volume is negligible: less than 3 % of imports of the like product, unless the countries that individually do not reach that 3% together add up to more than 7 %.
A relevant nuance for the US market: the 2% threshold applies to the original research, but in the annual administrative reviews the DOC applies a 0.5% threshold.
The same dumping, different authorities: a comparison between jurisdictions
| Jurisdiction | Who determines dumping | Who determines the damage | Practical feature to consider |
|---|---|---|---|
| USA | Department of Commerce (DOC) | International Trade Commission (USITC) | Retrospective system: final rights are settled in subsequent administrative reviews. China is treated as a non-market economy. |
| European Union | European Commission (DG Trade) | European Commission (DG Trade) | Margin on CIF frontier price; «significant distortions» to normal value; lower duty rule with exceptions since the 2018 modernization. |
| Canada | Border Services Agency (CBSA) | Canadian International Trade Tribunal (CITT) | Special Import Measures Act regime; applies normal values per exporter that function as minimum prices. |
| Mexico | UPCI, Ministry of Economy | UPCI, Ministry of Economy | Foreign Trade Law; unified procedure under a single authority. |
| Brazil | SECEX / DECOM | SECEX / DECOM | Regulated by Decree 8.058/2013; final decision on taxation in GECEX. |
| India | General Directorate of Commercial Remedies (DGTR) | General Directorate of Commercial Remedies (DGTR) | The DGTR recommends; the Ministry of Finance decides on the imposition. |
| Argentina | National Commission for Foreign Trade (CNCE) | National Commission for Foreign Trade (CNCE) | From the Decree 33/2025 (effective from April 2025), unified procedure in the CNCE; measures of up to 3 years, extendable only once for 2. |
The Agreement establishes the common ground; each Member implements it with its own organization and practices. In Latin America, these differences also have a cost in terms of effectiveness, as we discussed in our proposal for modernizing Latin American antidumping systems:
Regarding Argentina, see the context in Trade defense in Argentina in 2025, the regulations in National Resources y Decree 33/2025: Key aspects of the new Argentine antidumping system.
For other jurisdictions in the region, we recommend The application of antidumping and countervailing duties in Peru And, for Mexico, the Critique of the isolated thesis on antidumping resolutions in the amparo trial. A concrete example of how a case between two Latin American countries is resolved is Fiberglass wool: Argentina blocks Mexico.
👉 Does your company export to the United States, the European Union, or Latin America and want to estimate its exposure before a petitioner does? At Dumping Experts we assist exporters and importers in simulating margins and preparing questionnaire responses. Write to us.
What does this mean for your company?
If you export
- Calculate your own margin before anyone else. A sector analysis It allows you to anticipate which products are most vulnerable. The petitioner will do so with price lists and secondary data, almost always against them. Knowing your own situation allows you to decide in time.
- Review the pricing policy with your importing subsidiary. The profitability of resale at the destination can define the export price that the authority will use.
- Answer the questionnaires. Those who do not cooperate are subject to determinations based on «the facts of which there is knowledge» (Article 6.8 and Annex II), usually the information provided by the petitioner. The residual margin for non-cooperators is typically the highest in the case.
It matters
- Your supplier's dumping is your cost. The duty is paid upon dispatch to the market and, in certain cases, retroactively. Its impact depends on the form the measure takes, as we explain in Projected economic impact of antidumping duties.
- Participate as a stakeholder. It can provide evidence on causality, quality, and supply.
- Monitor open investigations with our Report on the existence of antidumping investigations.
👉 Join the Dumping Experts community. Access expert analysis, seminars and content on ongoing antidumping investigations in various jurisdictions. Learn about our seminars o contact us directly. You can also find specialists in our Directory of Experts and Professionals.
Conclusion
Dumping is not defined by the absolute price or by comparison with local competitors, but by the gap between what the exporter charges abroad and its normal value. This gap is determined by technical decisions—which sales are included, which costs are accepted, which adjustments are recognized, and which comparison method is applied—and each of these can shift the result from one side of the 2% threshold to the other.
Therefore, in trade defense, the decisive discussion is rarely whether or not dumping occurred in the abstract. how was it measured, something that is clearly seen in our case analysis. If you haven't read it yet, we recommend supplementing this analysis with Cost, Price, and Value: The Trinity That Explains Dumping, where we develop the economic logic behind these numbers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is dumping in simple terms?
It is exporting a product at a price lower than its normal value, which is generally the price at which that same product is sold in the domestic market of the exporting country.
Is selling below cost the same as dumping?
Not necessarily. Dumping can occur without selling at a lower cost if the export price is lower than the domestic price. And selling at a lower cost only matters when the tax authority uses computed value or excludes domestic sales at a lower cost.
How is the dumping margin calculated?
Subtracting the export price from the normal value, once both have been brought to the same commercial level and the differences adjusted, and expressing the result as a percentage of the export price. Some jurisdictions, such as the European Union, express it as a percentage of the CIF price at the border.
What level of dumping is sufficient to apply an antidumping duty?
Under the WTO Antidumping Agreement, a margin of less than 2% is considered de minimis and requires the investigation against that exporter or country to be closed. Furthermore, injury to the domestic industry and a causal link must be proven.
What is zeroing or reduction to zero?
This is the practice of zeroing out comparisons where the export price exceeds the normal value, thus inflating the margin. The WTO Appellate Body declared it incompatible with the Antidumping Agreement in several disputes against the United States.
Why does China receive different treatment in antidumping investigations?
Because some Members consider their domestic prices and costs to be distorted by the State. The United States treats it as a non-market economy; the European Union applies the methodology of significant distortions. In both cases, the normal value is constructed using external references.
Based on:
📚 WTO Antidumping System: Educational Text in Spanish
🏵️🎖️ Dr. María José Etulain Sórensen
Florida, United States (2022)
This publication is based on concepts developed in the work WTO Antidumping System, This text is aimed at professionals, companies, and students interested in understanding the practical workings of the World Trade Organization's antidumping system.
🏅 Dr. María José Etulain Sórensen
Reference Expert | Argentina
Lawyer, Master in Business Administration and specialist in international trade, customs duty and trade defense.
He has over 20 years of experience advising companies, industries, and business chambers in antidumping investigations, subsidies, safeguards, and international trade regulation. He has developed his career in both the public and private sectors, leading trade defense strategies and assisting companies in proceedings before national and international authorities.
Currently it is Director of MJE Global, founder of Dumping Experts y Coordinator of the Foreign Trade Committee of the Argentine-American Chamber of Commerce of Florida.
Likewise, he is currently enrolled in Master in Logistics & Supply Chain Management at Florida International University (FIU), strengthening its specialization in strategic analysis, international operations, global supply chains and data-driven decision making.
His experience combines cost structure analysis, interpretation of foreign trade data, regulatory risk assessment, and strategy design for complex international environments.
Strategic advice on trade defense and foreign trade
With over 20 years of experience, MJE Foreign Trade It provides specialized advice to companies, industries and business chambers on antidumping investigations, countervailing measures, safeguards, customs law, international trade, temporary import and international expansion strategies.
Our approach combines technical expertise, strategic vision, and personalized support to help organizations manage risks, comply with regulations, and strengthen their international competitiveness.
Participate in the Dumping Experts Community
Dumping Experts brings together professionals, academics, companies and specialists interested in the study of antidumping investigations and trade defense measures.
📩 We invite our members to share articles, case analyses, sector studies, regulatory commentaries, and research to contribute to the development of a specialized Spanish-speaking community.